Monday, July 27, 2020

Bruni: "So This is Your Idea of Freedom?"

July 23, 2020


From Frank Bruni, one of my fave columnists, in a New York Times newsletter yesterday:

"Our struggle with this pandemic has convinced me that somewhere along the way, we went from celebrating individual liberty to fetishizing it, so that for too many Americans, all sense of civic obligation and communal good went out the window," Bruni wrote. We seem to conflate freedom with selfishness, convenience, and personal comfort, he adds. 

Bruni is talking about people who refuse to wear masks. They're among a number of Americans who believe that personal freedom must be protected at all costs, even if the costs are borne by others who suffer for their (possibly cockamamie) ideas and behavior. In short, individual freedom trumps community interests.

Conservatives are like
Cyrano de Bergerac:
They stand proud and alone 
because they're ugly
and nobody loves them.
(Just kidding! Sorry, Mom!)

"[This] has been the core animating theory behind the American gun rights movement: reduce the debate to an absolutist fight about freedom, wrote Dahlia Lithwick in Slate.com this May, "that eventually narcotizes an entire population into believing that the cost of true liberty is tens of thousands of avoidable gun deaths each year."

Thus, she says, any step toward gun regulation "is cast as a dire step toward tyranny."

We've heard that the only statistically measurable difference between liberals and conservatives is that liberals have a higher tolerance for things that are disgusting (seriously!).

It's debatable that such a clear distinction has been overlooked in studies seeking the difference between liberals and conservatives. The only measurable statistical difference, we've heard, is that liberals have a higher tolerance for things that are disgusting (seriously!).

It's "I did it my way" versus "Lean on me."

Is this the real difference between liberals and conservatives -- a desire to see the community safe, housed, and free to speak versus a desire to stand high and alone against a teeming mass of strangers?

Did the conservative "regulate me not" drive America's sense of manifest destiny -- or excuse it? What is the weakness in either point of view?



Photo: "Bergerac_Cyrano" by dadotres is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/05/freedom-li

No comments:

Post a Comment

8/28/21 Once Again, the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally is a COVID19 Super-Spreader

In 2020, the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally was linked to 649 COVID19 cases in 29 states, a CDC study said. In 2021, the rally did much the same t...